I've used many eyebrow pencils/eyebrow kits over the years and at last have found my ultimate favourite. The Kevyn Aucoin Precision Brow Pencil has just the right texture and hardness for drawing on eyebrow hairs that look natural. The packaging is slick with a slim retractable tube and an attached brow spoolie for grooming.
Pros: Retractable tube means no sharpening
Cons: Only 2 colours in the range, expensive
Texture: Matt and not waxy, stays on all day
Repurchase: Most definitely, I love it